marxisforbros:captain-acab:themildestofwriters:shittymoviedetails:they all tripped and scattered pap
marxisforbros:captain-acab:themildestofwriters:shittymoviedetails:they all tripped and scattered papers onto the ground and no one helps them and that’s how they became villainsTo be fair, Selina Kyle and Pamela Isley were straight up murdered. For all we know, Selina is a Revenant and Pamela is in a resurrective mind altered state that results in homicidal tendencies. Maybe Barbra Minerva is also in an altered state of mind due to the plot thing, and Edward Nigma had his brain turned to gush through self experimentation, so I don’t think it’s entirely a case for “I’m a clumsy nerd who gets bullied by people for being Weird so now I’m going to be evil, now.”You’re missing the point. Especially as a self-professed writing blog, you should recognize that tropes stem from the conscious decision-making of real-life writers, not the fiction characters they choose to write.In each of the screenshots, the writers made the decision to write each villain as a weird-hair big-glasses nerd that nobody likes, then turn them into a villain, and that is the behavior we need to examine.Is it a fantasy? Do the writers imagine themselves as the nerds (which, knowing several film writers, they probably did feel like at multiple points in their lives), and this is them fantasizing about getting revenge on people who bullied them?Or is it apologism? Are they showing us the people they find weird or unlikable and showing that, aha! These people were only a step away from being evil anyway, so bullying them was justified!Or is it something else entirely? Good trope analysis, but again; Selina Kyle was a secretary murdered by her wealthy boss, not “a nerd bullied into becoming a villain because she had no friends”. To lump her into that category is to erase the narrative of powerful men getting away with violence towards women. Selina Kyle: Intimidate me, bully me if it makes you feel big. I mean it’s not like you can just kill me. Max Shreck: Actually, it’s a lot like that.She became an anti-hero that sought revenge (Killing her boss) instead of justice (Allowing Batman to hand him over to the authorities), because unlike Bruce Wayne she recognized that the wealthy are beyond justice. Her appearance is better interpreted as an example of The Makeover/The Glasses Gotta Go, same lazy character design, but not the same trope. -- source link